Blue Moon

Blue Moon

Director:

Richard Linklater

Year:

2025

Country:

United States

Stars:

Ethan Hawke, Andrew Scott

Hart and soul

By Michael J. Roberts

"I would have loved to have been a '40s studio director like Vincente Minnelli. You ended up with a real diverse career. Now you don't get a call from Darryl F. Zanuck saying, 'Come do this movie on Monday'. So you have to do it on your own." ~ Richard Linklater

When the history of film in the first quarter of the 21st century is written a lot of words will be wasted on the Superhero cycle that dominated the output and commercial focus of Hollywood and beyond – but cinema lovers will remember the fine American auteurs who pursued a different kind of filmmaking and prime amongst them will be Richard Linklater. Linklater had broken through in the world of Independent Cinema in the early 1990s with Slacker and Dazed and Confused and went on to provide several mainstream hits interspersed with artier or quirkier projects, but all his work remained true to a personal vision. In 2026 he released two films, Nouvelle Vague – a close look at the making of Jean-Luc Godard’s groundbreaking Breathless, and Blue Moon, which centres on an evening in the life of songwriter Lorenz Hart and starring his close and frequent collaborator Ethan Hawke. 

Lorenz Hart (Ethan Hawke) is sitting in the balcony of a Broadway theatre with his mother watching the opening night of Oklahoma! - a new musical by his writing partner of nearly 25 years, Richard Rodgers. Hart leaves early to the bar at Sardi’s and regales Eddie the barman (Bobby Cannavale) and a couple of patrons with tales of the show and of his romantic pursuit of Elizabeth (Margaret Qualley), a young female student, whose arrival is imminent. Rodgers (Andrew Scott) and Hammerstein arrive for the after-show party and Hart tries to have a conciliatory conversation with Rodgers amongst the hustle and throng whilst Elizabeth is keen on being introduced to Rodgers. 

The piece is a tour de force for Ethan Hawke who inhabits the role so totally it seems as easy as breathing, also carrying off the conceit that he is as small of stature as Hart was, barely 5 feet tall. To counter his plain appearance and jockey-like height, Hart developed a keening and biting wit and Hawke chews on the delicious lines afforded in Robert Kaplow’s script as he cajoles and entertains in equal measure through the films various setups. Kaplow had written the 2003 novel Me and Orson Welles and Linklater directed the film adaptation in 2008, and the two concocted the idea for Blue Moon shortly after with Hawke an eager co-conspirator,but apparently, they deemed he was too young at the time, so they waited until he had what Linklater wanted, ‘more lines on his face.’ 

Linklater and Kaplow knew there was an underlying sadness in Hart’s bravura, covering up so many of his insecurities as he saw his life defining, artistic partnership slip away. Rodgers is compactly and delicately played by Andrew Scott, as a man torn by his affection for Hart but over the demands of dealing with his friend’s self-destructive demons. Rodgers was more self-assured (the son of middle-class Jewish parents, his father a physician), even if he suffered from alcoholism too, and had a more conventional personal life and a mild handsomeness to contrast Hart’s appearance. Hart had refused to work on the adaptation of the source play for Oklahoma! and Rodgers worked with a new partner, Oscar Hammerstein II, an old friend of the pair and a frequent collaborator with Jerome Kern – their biggest hit was Showboat. Hart knew Rodgers was one of the master tunesmiths in American music history, a genius of melody as accomplished as Gershwin or Kern, so he knew the power of collaborating with someone so talented and was obviously terrified of losing his partner permanently to Hammerstein.  
 
This dilemma lies at the heart of Blue Moon and Kaplow teases it out over a couple of key conversations with people in the bar, especially the character E.B. White (Patrick Kennedy) and the writer of the novel Stuart Little. Linklater sets the table for a tense meeting of Rodgers and Hart once Rodgers arrives with his entourage post show – Rodgers knows Hart looks down upon the show, but Hart knows its populist bent will see it become a huge success – the two dance around each other as Hart tries to conceal his desperation and Rodgers has enough residual affection for their partnership to throw him a bone; a reworking of their old hit, A Connecticut Yankee. To balance the tension and melancholy Kaplow seeds a couple of conceits along with the ‘Stuart’ suggestion Hart makes to White for the name of his fictional mouse with Elizabeth bringing in her preppie friend who wants to direct, George Roy Hill, and Hart tells him to focus on ‘friendship’ - Hill would famously direct buddy films Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid and The Sting et al. He also has a scene where Hammerstein has a young acolyte tagging along, Stevie, who is Stephen Sondheim, who Hart also blesses with a pearl of wisdom. Cannavale is fine as the friendly barman trying to keep Hart on the straight and narrow and Qualley is touching as the young woman who knows where the main game is played.

Broadway (and Hollywood) was a magnet for talent of all kinds in the first quarter of the 20th century and not unusually much of the talented, and the untalented too, were amongst the better-looking cohort of humans on the planet. In this environment the plain and unattractive stood little chance of success in the public facing arts, but as a backroom songwriter Lorenz Hart came into his own. A literate and witty man he eventually evolved a persona that was part Cyrano de Bergerac and part Triumph the Insult Comic Dog (especially the ubiquitous cigar) as a man who was a ‘fool for beauty’ and someone who idealised the higher yearnings of love.The heart of a poet trapped in the body of a stunted, ugly duckling who found himself in a golden pond of gorgeous birds who would forever be beyond his reach is the fuel that drove hart to excel as a songsmith of the first rank.  

Blue Moon is a small and precious gem from Richard Linklater, a compact period piece that looks superb and a gorgeous realisation and a not so funny valentine to a bygone Broadway era centred on the desperation of a man on the edge, trying to keep afloat against his own self-destructive impulses. The humour is arch, as befits the wit of Hart who brought a rapier tongue and keen insights into his observations, even at his own expense – he dismissed the pianist in the bar playing Blue Moon when he entered as his worst lyric (it was their biggest hit), but as it was replayed upon his exit he turned around and rethought it, ‘You know it’s not that bad... at least it’s not Surrey With The Fuckin’ Fringe on Top.’ Touche.  

Blue Moon 1a Blue Moon 2 Blue Moon 3 Blue Moon 4 Blue Moon 5 Blue Moon 6 Blue Moon 7